By Councillor Gail Macgregor, COSLA Environment & Economy Spokesperson.
To grow the economy, Scotland needs an empowered and flexible Local Government. New structures and boundaries will achieve little if councils are still expected to deliver economic renewal with shrinking capacity, short-term funding and too few levers over the forces shaping their places.
We are not arguing against change, but we must be clear about what change is meant to achieve. Local Government is already one of the cornerstones of Scotland’s economy. Across all 32 council areas, authorities turn national ambition into practical support for local workers, businesses and communities. They deliver employability services, run Business Gateway, lead regeneration, convene regional partnerships and help unlock land, infrastructure and investment. They also carry much of the practical burden of the just transition, digital inclusion and community wealth building. This is not administrative background work; it is part of delivering essential services and economic infrastructure which fuel national economic growth and prosperity.
The results show the value of that local presence. Since 2019, council employability services have engaged more than 92,000 people, generated around 70,000 positive outcomes and helped almost 30,000 people into work. Over the past five years, Business Gateway has supported more than 200,000 unique customers, contributing to more than 36,000 start-ups and 50,000 jobs. Through procurement, assets and partnerships, councils also keep wealth circulating within communities and reach people and firms that standardised national programmes often miss.
And yet the capacity that produced those results is being steadily stripped away. Core funding has barely moved in real terms. Ring-fenced funding now absorbs a substantial share of revenue, while the scope for another round of efficiency savings is exhausted. Economic development funding reported through the relevant local authority indicators fell from £171 million in 2021/22 to £117 million in 2023/24, with rural and island councils particularly exposed. Business Gateway’s core budget has not risen since responsibility transferred to Local Government in 2008. If it had kept pace with inflation, it would now stand at about £28.3 million. Instead, it remains £16.3 million.
It is not only the amount of money that matters; it is the way the money arrives. Annual allocations, competitive pots and centrally designed programmes are a poor fit for work built on continuity. Capital projects need long lead times. Employability and business support depend on trusted relationships and experienced staff. Neither can be switched off and restarted without a cost. Late guidance and sudden changes prompt redundancy notices, stall projects and diminish their impact, and leave councils managing immediate crises instead of planning for the future. Grangemouth, Mossmorran and other centres of industrial change have already shown the price of reacting late rather than preparing early.
This is where the debate about reform should begin, and why Local Government needs a fairer funding settlement in this year’s budget. Predictable multi-year funding, greater freedom over spending and priorities, transparent allocation methods are essential to increase the role councils play in shaping regional economies. Different places should be able to develop arrangements that reflect their circumstances, rather than being forced into a single national model. National and Local Government, enterprise agencies, employers and the third sector also need clearer responsibilities and shared accountability for what they achieve.
We do not need the assumption that institutional architecture can substitute for economic capacity or automatically leads to economic growth. A new regional body, a redrawn boundary or a revised partnership board will not compensate for weak investment, insecure work, poor infrastructure, gaps in childcare, ill health or a shortage of affordable housing.
The just transition exposes the same flaw in the current approach. Local authorities can align planning, infrastructure, skills and business support with net zero, but decarbonisation will not be just unless it creates secure work and protects those least able to absorb the costs. Climate adaptation must sit within economic planning because the consequences of inaction will fall hardest on vulnerable households and places. Powers on paper are not enough: councils also need data, specialist staff and investment. Devolution without capacity simply devolves responsibility for failure.
Any change to the structures of our public services needs to be rooted in delivering better outcomes for people and businesses in our local communities and come with the resources to deliver them. Reform could help small firms grow, workers move into low-carbon industries, communities manage climate risk, and tackle economic inactivity driven by health, caring, skills, social security and labour demand. For reform to be successful it needs to be done in collaboration with Local Government, taking on board the views of our local businesses and communities, and resourced appropriately.
A credible settlement should instead rest on four principles: certainty, clarity, flexibility and prosperity. Certainty means ending the churn of short-lived funds. Clarity means connecting national strategy to the realities of doing business and finding work in different parts of Scotland. Flexibility means allowing councils to organise employment support, childcare, transport and skills around people, not programmes. Prosperity means backing proven services such as Business Gateway and the local institutions that turn national priorities into jobs, stronger firms and more resilient communities.
This also demands change in how economic development is viewed when public spending decisions are made. Too often it is treated as discretionary - a useful extra when budgets allow. In reality, stronger local economies raise incomes and productivity, broaden the tax base to ease pressure on public services, and are vital in enabling the delivery of national priorities such as Community Wealth Building. Rebuilding local economic capacity is therefore not separate from fiscal sustainability or public service reform. It is essential to both.
Scotland should pursue structural reform where it gives communities more influence and enables institutions to work better. But we must stop asking reorganisation to fix problems it cannot solve. Local Government and the wider economy do not principally suffer from a lack of structure, but a shortage of sustained investment, skilled capacity, policy coherence and the power to act before a crisis takes hold. Unless Scotland also confronts low productivity, economic inactivity, inequality, fragile infrastructure and the transition to net zero, rearranging responsibilities will simply rearrange the pressure. Reform the system, certainly - but fund the capacity to make reform count.